Brazing-Drawing Challenge – Part 2 (Answers)

We have a winner in the brazing-drawing challenge that I presented to you last month in this column. Peter Ditzel, Principal Engineer (M&P) at Parker Hannifin in Mentor, Ohio was the first respondent to find at least seven (7) brazing errors in the drawing as it relates to vacuum-brazing of aluminum alloys, and thus qualifies to receive a 10% discount on a registration for himself (or for a fellow employee there at Parker in Mentor, Ohio) to either one of my two upcoming 3-day brazing-training seminars in Spartanburg, SC (October 1-3) or in Simsbury, CT (Nov. 12-14, 2019). Congratulations, Peter! Please contact me at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. to take advantage of this discount for yourself or for a co-worker!

Fig. 1 shows the challenge-drawing once again. A friend of mine in the brazing world created an unusual brazing assembly-drawing as a “spoof” or “gag”, and intentionally included at least seven (7) brazing “no-no’s” that he himself had learned during a seminar that he attended earlier that year. He sent this “gag” assembly-drawing to me, humorously suggesting it might be a tool that I could use in my teaching to help other people learn what they should NOT do when vacuum-brazing aluminum alloys!

Last Updated on Friday, 06 September 2019 17:27

Hits: 635

Read more: Brazing-Drawing Challenge – Part 2 (Answers)

Brazing-Drawing Challenge

Shown in Fig. 1 is a drawing of an aluminum part that is to be vacuum-brazed. Are all the drawing callouts correct from a brazing perspective? Please examine the drawing carefully, and see if you can correctly find seven (7) things that are wrong with that assembly drawing. You’ll find things in the procedure-notes, and perhaps in the design itself. Send your list of “findings” to dan.kay (at) A description of each of these seven items will be discussed in detail in next month’s article (“Brazing-Drawing Challenge, Part 2) so that you can see what I strongly recommend that you should NOT do when vacuum brazing aluminum parts.

If you have attended one of my intensive 3-day brazing-training seminars, then you should be able to locate all of the mistakes. But if you haven’t attended one of my programs, then I hope you’ll find this to be an interesting challenge for you.

The person who is the first to correctly identify the “problems” in this assembly-drawing will be recognized personally in this column next month, and will also qualify for a 10% discount on a seminar-registration (That’s worth more than US$ 195) for themselves (or for one of their fellow workers at the same work-location) to attend either one of my two (2) brazing training seminars this fall in either Spartanburg, South Carolina (Oct.1-3) or in Simsbury, Connecticut (Nov. 9-11).

Last Updated on Wednesday, 14 August 2019 16:44

Hits: 750

Read more: Brazing-Drawing Challenge

Temperature Uniformity Survey (TUS) Fixturing

It is very important that any company operating a brazing furnace (be it an atmosphere furnace or a vacuum furnace) should know how uniform the temperature is throughout their brazing furnace during the entire brazing cycle. This temperature uniformity is typically measured by placing a special test-rack into the furnace chamber, as shown in Fig. 1, to which thermocouples (TC’s) are attached.

Accurately controlling temperature (and temp-uniformity) throughout a brazing cycle is essential, and you would think that anyone involved in operating brazing furnaces would not only understand this but would also take needed steps to ensure the accuracy and control of temperature throughout each of their brazing cycles. Surprisingly that is not always the case, as I have seen over the years.

Last Updated on Thursday, 11 July 2019 16:39

Hits: 696

Read more: Temperature Uniformity Survey (TUS) Fixturing

“Dummy-blocks” used in Brazing Furnaces

When parts are to be furnace-brazed in commercial job-shop vacuum furnaces or in standard atmosphere furnaces, they are typically placed on a rack inside the furnace, and then the furnace door is closed, thus completely hiding those parts from view. Once the actual furnace brazing-cycle begins inside that furnace, you really don’t know what’s happening to those parts, since you can’t see them. The only practical way to determine if they are actually being successfully brazed is to watch the furnace’s instrument panel in order to find out what’s happening inside the furnace (temperature, vacuum level, leak-up rates, etc.). Obviously, when you open the furnace door after the brazing cycle is over you will quickly see the results of the brazing cycle, which you hope will be fine. But when (not IF, but WHEN) something goes wrong with one of your brazing runs, and you see that the parts did not braze well (or did not braze at all), then the importance of properly instrumenting your brazing load will become very clear to you!

By the phrase “properly instrumenting your brazing load” I am primarily referring to the proper use of thermocouples (TC’s) to accurately monitor and record the temperatures being experienced by the parts themselves as they are being brazed! This is very important. As shown in Fig. 1, TC’s that are attached to the parts being brazed are known as “load-TC’s” since each such assembly is part of the “load” going into the furnace to be brazed.

Last Updated on Thursday, 13 June 2019 16:32

Hits: 669

Read more: “Dummy-blocks” used in Brazing Furnaces

Controlled “Heat-down” For Vacuum Brazing

When parts are brazed in a vacuum furnace, distortion of those brazed assemblies can easily happen. To prevent parts from distorting, people have tried a variety of things, including extended stress-relieving of components prior to assembling those parts for brazing, the use of rigid fixturing to try to keep parts from moving during a brazing cycle, and even making components heavier and more massive in order to make them more distortion-resistant. Distortion still occurs.

Yes, some of these things, such as stress-relief heat-treatment prior to brazing might help to some extent, but it is not the answer to controlling distortion during any furnace brazing cycle. The real key to controlling distortion is to control the heating and cooling rates used in the brazing cycle. Shown in Fig. 1 is an illustration of what a typical furnace brazing cycle might look like, in which the furnace temp is controlled by the “Furnace thermocouple (TC)” shown on the left side of the chart, and three (3) load TC’s are used on one part to see the temperature-spread (temp-differential, or delta-T) within that one part.

Last Updated on Thursday, 25 April 2019 15:43

Hits: 1187

Read more: Controlled “Heat-down” For Vacuum Brazing

Magnesium (Mg) Vapor in Vacuum-Furnaces Used for Brazing Aluminum Components

As mentioned in my article last month, it is critically important to be aware of the vapor pressures of any materials that are processed at elevated temperatures in a vacuum-furnace, because a vacuum can effectively lower the temperature at which a particular material will volatilize (outgas). We learned that you should never try to vacuum-braze brass, a copper-alloy which contains zinc (Zn), because Zn is a metallic element which can easily volatize when heated. The same is true for cadmium (Cd), a metallic element that is added to a number of silver-based brazing filler metals (BFMs) to lower its melting temp and improve wetting (such as in AWS A5.8, Class BAg-1).

Magnesium (Mg) is another metal (see Fig. 1) that, when heated in a vacuum, can also volatilize quite easily, and should therefore (like Zn and Cd) never be used in any vacuum furnace used for high-temp aerospace brazing of stainless or super-alloy base metals, since Mg contamination in such furnaces could ruin the furnace, rendering it non-useable ever again for any critical high-temp aerospace applications.

Does this rule out Mg from ever being used in any vacuum furnace? No, it does not. Some vacuum furnaces are built with the express purpose of allowing Mg to be used in them when brazing one specific type of base metal – aluminum (or aluminum as many prefer to spell it)! Vacuum furnaces built for brazing aluminum are unique – they are built to operate at just about half the temperature needed for high-temp aero brazing, they use different kinds of metals for their heating elements and hot-zones, and have much tighter temp-control than their higher-temp aerospace-brazing cousins. We’ve discussed all this before in previous articles on the subject.

Don’t Vacuum-Braze Metals Containing Zinc

Vacuum brazing is growing in many brazing shops today, to handle the complex needs of the aerospace, medical, and consumer-goods industries. The primary reason for this is that the amount of oxygen in any good vacuum atmosphere is so small that no oxidation of parts should ever occur, and thus, parts can be brazed without the need for any protective fluxes, and those surfaces can be kept bright and clean throughout the brazing process with no post-braze cleaning needed. That’s great! But, are there any “negatives” to brazing in a vacuum furnace?

WARNING: Yes, there are some significant potential problems that must be understood (and avoided) when vacuum brazing and the first one relates to the chemistry of each of the metals involved in the brazing process! Some metals contain zinc, such as the brass components in Fig. 1 that have been assembled for brazing. Zinc can easily volatilize (turn into a gaseous vapor) when heated, which could then badly contaminate (and possibly ruin) your vacuum furnace!

Cadmium (Cd), lead (Pb), and magnesium (Mg) are additional examples of metals that also easily volatilize when heated, and must be avoided when vacuum-brazing. I’ll look at the magnesium problem further in next month’s article. Let’s examine this potential volatilization problem further by studying the chart shown in Fig. 2. This chart shows a series of what are called “vapor pressure curves” for a number of common metallic elements.

Last Updated on Tuesday, 12 March 2019 21:23

Hits: 1592

Read more: Don’t Vacuum-Braze Metals Containing Zinc

Log in to your account or